Sports
The latest edition
Gathering the headlines…
Connecting you to stories from original sources.
The latest edition
Gathering the headlines…
Connecting you to stories from original sources.
Your daily perspective.
Culture · News article
On Who Asked You, hosts Ivy Frater and Josie Belfer talked with Eliza Martin about her column Record Scratch and her opinions on this year’s Grammy nominations. They discuss the nomination process, whether the Grammys prioritizing commercial success over critical acclaim, and share which artist they think deserves more recognition.
IVY FRATER: From The Daily Northwestern, I’m Ivy Frater.
JOSIE BELFER: And I’m Josie Belfer.
IVY FRATER: And this is Who Asked You, a podcast capturing opinions on the issues that matter to us and to you.
[music]
So this week, we’re going to talk to Eliza about her column, “Record Scratch.” She recently wrote about her opinion on the Grammy nominations, which just dropped.
JOSIE BELFER: From what I’ve seen on the internet, I know like over the past few years, the Grammy nominations have been the source of some discussion and maybe even some drama where people have kind of like, discussed maybe the Grammys as a whole need to be reconsidered and their nomination process needs to be reconsidered. So I was just wondering like, if you had any thoughts on the Grammys and the trends that you’ve seen in the Grammys and how that aligns with this year?
ELIZA MARTIN: My take on the Grammys overall, is that it’s fundamentally an imperfect system because there’s no real way to decide which song, artist or album was the best or most important of a given year. That’s so subjective.
I think with the Grammys, they go back and forth from picking albums or artists that were the most popular and really dominated the charts, versus picking more critically acclaimed, innovative work. And either way, they get a lot of criticism for it because people either say, there have been like, Taylor Swift winning Album of the Year over Kendrick Lamar, got a ton of backlash because his album was more politically groundbreaking. But then, you also see Jon Batiste winning Album of the Year and people saying, “I have no idea who this is.” So, there’s no real winning, and I am to expect that I’ll be frustrated with at least some of the results.
IVY FRATER: Do you have a favorite song or artist or album that wasn’t nominated that you think should’ve been, or that was snubbed by the Grammys this year?
ELIZA MARTIN: I was a little bit surprised that Harry Styles wasn’t nominated because his last album, “Harry’s House,” won Album of the Year in 2023. I was really surprised that Noah Kahan wasn’t up for Album of the Year for “The Great Divide.” I actually think there was space for at least one of them because Taylor Swift’s album was terrible this year, but that’s just my personal take.
JOSIE BELFER: I know you discussed in your article that your ideal winner would be Phoebe Bridgers, but I was just wondering if you had any other people that, based on the nominations, you were really rooting for?
ELIZA MARTIN: Yeah, like I wrote about in my column, Phoebe Bridgers had my favorite album of the year, but I just think she hasn’t had enough time, number one, and number two, her music isn’t really fit for like, chart-topping success, and it doesn’t appeal to all audiences. So I just don’t know what her odds are.
But other artists I’m rooting for, I’d really, really like to see Slayyyter get a win. I would like to see Rosalía and Raye get recognition for their more innovative work this year, and just those artists who have been working for a long time and are doing interesting things as opposed to just making more surface-level music.
IVY FRATER: I know you mentioned Taylor Swift a little bit earlier. As someone who used to be like a really big Taylor Swift fan and now, I really did not like her most recent albums. Do you think that she’s just nominated because she’s Taylor Swift? Will she ever release an album that’s not nominated?
ELIZA MARTIN: I feel like in my column, I’ve been talking a lot about Taylor Swift, so I’m not obsessed with her, but here she is again. And honestly, the thing about Taylor Swift is you can say this album was terrible, but it did have a lot of success. A lot of people listen to it, and she has a huge fanbase that will listen to and defend anything she puts out. And so I think the Grammys can continue arguing that it’s valid for them to nominate her. I personally just did not think this album was to the standard of being considered for Album of the Year when she’s already won that several times before.
JOSIE BELFER: Recently, I’ve been watching the Swiftologist, which, contrary to what you may think, he is actually sometimes very critical of Taylor Swift, and especially her new album. But, I was wondering if you have any, like, favorite online critics that you go to for either Grammy commentary or, like, other commentary on music.
ELIZA MARTIN: Well, whenever I write music reviews for The Daily, I write a lot of Liner Notes, album reviews. I always go and look at other reviews of the album, typically from Rolling Stone, Pitchfork, et cetera. But I like to see what other people are saying. I also volunteer as a radio DJ, and so I like listening to other shows on my station and hearing other DJs speak about the music they’re interested in, whether it’s new releases or oldies or more niche stuff. But other than that, I just see what comes up on my social media.
IVY FRATER: Well, thank you, Eliza, for talking with us. And we loved having your column this quarter; it was super fun. I don’t think The Daily’s ever done a music column, so it was really cool.
From The Daily Northwestern, I’m Ivy Frater.
JOSIE BELFER: And I’m Josie Belfer.
[music]
IVY FRATER: This episode was written by Ivy Frater and Josie Belfer, and produced by Gloria Ngwa.
The audio editor is Emerson Leger. The multimedia managing editors are Siri Reddy, Liam Barrett, and Josh Singer. The editor in chief is Anavi Prakash.
Follow us on X and Instagram @thedailynu.
Email: [email protected] X: @IvyFrater
Email: [email protected]
Email: [email protected] X: @gloriangwa_
Related Stories: — Who Asked You: Electoral systems and the importance of competitive elections — Who Asked You: Internet culture, social media addiction and the ‘scroll pill’ — Who Asked You: Wedding films and finding love at NU